Selling your agency? Evaluate the buyer, not just their offer.

Acquisition entrepreneurs discuss successful and unsuccessful business searches at the 2026 Booth–Kellogg ETA Conference in Chicago.
Written by: Karl Sakas

An agency owner I advised received an acquisition inquiry that seemed worth pursuing. The buyer was already acquiring agencies, and the conversations went well enough that my client flew to their headquarters.

The visit helped him make a decision… although probably not the one the buyer expected. Their cultures were too different. He couldn’t picture his team staying, and he wouldn’t want to work there himself. He withdrew before signing a letter of intent.

That was a useful trip. He learned something he needed to know while it was still relatively easy to walk away.

When someone offers to buy your agency, it’s easy to get caught up in their evaluation of you. Will they like the numbers? What will they pay? What might they discover in due diligence?

Meanwhile, you have some investigating to do, too.

In October 2026, I attended my third Booth–Kellogg Entrepreneurship Through Acquisition (ETA) Conference in Chicago. The event brings together prospective business buyers, investors, lenders, and advisors to discuss acquiring and operating established companies.

Most attendees were approaching acquisitions from the buyer’s perspective. I was there to understand what agency owners should know about the people who might buy their businesses.

This article is 5,000+ words. Some of the lessons below come directly from conference sessions and 1:1 conversations. Others come from my experience advising agency owners on growth, leadership succession, and potential exits.

During the Chicago event, I kept thinking about what my clients would want to know before agreeing to sell. For example:

  • Can this buyer complete the acquisition?
  • Can they actually run the agency afterward?
  • Would their plans give you the exit you’re looking for?

Those questions apply whether you received an unsolicited email or your M&A advisor introduced the buyer through a formal sale process.

Here’s how I’d approach the evaluation, starting with questions that can save you time, then moving into the work you should do before committing. Your M&A advisor, accountant, and transaction attorney should be involved along the way. My focus here is the business and leadership side of the decision.

1. Get clear on what you need from the sale

Before you get attached to a buyer’s offer, write down your ideal outcome, minimum acceptable outcome, and worst-case scenario.

I recommend this in my guide to handling unsolicited acquisition offers, too. It gives you something to refer to when a buyer proposes an appealing number with less-appealing conditions.

Start with the money, but don’t end there. How much do you need at closing? How much uncertainty can you tolerate around later payments? How long are you willing to keep working, and what work are you willing to do?

Be specific about what you want to stop doing. You might enjoy advising clients but be finished with managing employees. You might want to keep leading the agency without having your family’s finances so dependent on its performance. Or you might be ready to leave entirely.

Suppose you want to be out of day-to-day management within a year. A buyer who expects you to remain CEO for three years is proposing something that doesn’t meet that goal. You need to discuss it early, regardless of how much you like the buyer.

Consider your employees and clients, too. Which commitments matter most to you? Would you accept a name change if the leadership team stayed? Would you accept some integration if it gave your team better career opportunities?

Separate the things you genuinely need from the things you’d prefer. Otherwise, everything becomes a dealbreaker—or you discover too late that you gave up something important.

If you have business partners, get aligned before serious buyer discussions. One owner might want to retire while another hopes to build a career within the acquiring company. Those goals aren’t necessarily incompatible, but the buyer needs to know about both.

And be honest about your readiness. It’s fine to explore what a future sale could look like. Just say that. Don’t present yourself as ready to transact when you’re mainly curious about what someone might pay.

2. Fast fail: Qualify the buyer before investing months

You don’t need to investigate every detail before a second call. You do need to establish whether there’s enough of a fit to justify spending more time.

I’d start with five questions.

Who is actually buying, and who else needs to approve?

Find out whether you’re speaking with the prospective owner, an employee finding acquisition opportunities, or an intermediary representing someone else.

Then ask who else must approve the transaction. Your contact might be enthusiastic, but who controls the money? Who can say no?

It’s also worth understanding where they are in their search. During a conference panel comparing successful and unsuccessful acquisition searches, one participant described initially talking with owners partly to learn about industries and practice their approach. Later, they focused on conversations that could lead to an offer.

That’s understandable. Everyone has to learn. But you should know whether you’re talking with someone who is seriously considering your agency or someone who is still deciding what kind of business they want.

A useful question:

“How settled are you on acquiring an agency, and what would need to happen for you to seriously pursue ours?”

You might decide that an exploratory conversation is worthwhile. That doesn’t mean you need to provide unlimited meetings and detailed financial information.

Why do they want your agency?

Ask the buyer to explain why your agency fits what they’re looking for.

Maybe it’s your specialization, leadership team, client relationships, or recurring revenue. Maybe they want to enter a market where you already have credibility.

Whatever the reason, they should be able to explain it.

“Great team and lots of growth potential” could describe hundreds of agencies. Ask what they see in yours, what they would preserve, and what they believe they could improve.

In my guide to acquiring another agency, I recommend that buyers develop an investment thesis: what they want to buy, why they want it, and how the acquisition would help. Flip that advice around. Ask how your agency fits the buyer’s thesis—and what would make them decline to buy your agency. If their criteria keep changing, they may still be figuring out what they want.

You don’t need to agree with all their ideas. But you should understand why they’re interested and whether their expectations seem reasonable.

How would they pay for the acquisition?

Find out what money is available, what is conditional, and what still needs to be raised or approved.

“We have investors” needs a follow-up. So does “Our bank likes the deal.”

During a conference panel on SBA 7(a) acquisition financing, lenders pushed back on brokers advertising businesses as “SBA-approved.” A sell-side broker’s evaluation is a data point, but it’s not the same as a lender telling a buyer, “yes, we’ve approved your financing for this particular deal.”

You still need to consider the buyer’s finances, post-deal compensation needs, experience, and proposed deal—and what you need from an exit.

By your second meeting, I’d ask the acquirer:

“Which parts of your financing plan have been reviewed? By whom? What remains unresolved?”

Financing doesn’t have to be finalized before you speak. You’re looking for a reasonable plan and an understanding of what still needs to happen.

You also need to know what their financing means for you. If the plan depends on you accepting substantial deferred payments, find that out now.

What do they need from you after closing?

Ask about your role before anyone assumes you’ll be available indefinitely.

Would you continue leading the agency? Introduce the buyer to clients? Sell new business? Help integrate the companies? For how long, and reporting to whom? How would things wind down over time?

I’d ask:

“Which of my current responsibilities would you take over, which would go to our team, and where would you need to hire?”

Be careful with vague titles. “Advisor” could mean a monthly call—or being available 24/7 whenever something goes wrong. Ask what an ordinary week would look like, including hours, responsibilities, and decision-making authority.

Then compare that with the reasons you wanted to sell.

What kind of deal are they considering?

You don’t need to negotiate the purchase agreement in the first meeting. But you should understand the broad proposal.

Are they buying the entire agency or a controlling interest? How much would they expect to pay at closing? Would they want seller financing, an earnout, or for you to retain equity?

Ask whether their lender or investors have considered that structure. A proposal that sounds reasonable to the person across the table may not be acceptable to whoever is funding it.

The first few conversations should help you decide whether to continue—not make you feel obligated to continue.

If there’s a fundamental mismatch, a polite response is enough:

“Thanks for the interest. We’re looking for a different transition and payment structure, so I don’t think this is the right fit.”

If the answers are promising but incomplete, agree on what needs to happen next. You still have an agency to run.

3. Find out who would own and run the agency

Once there’s a possible fit, you can spend more time investigating the buyer’s plans and experience.

Follow the money and decision-making authority

The person you enjoy talking with may not have final authority after the acquisition.

Ask who would approve budgets, appoint leaders, and decide whether to sell the business again. What are the investors expecting? What happens if growth falls short of the plan?

In the conference keynote, investor Will Thorndike, author of The Outsiders, discussed Equity Efficient Serial Acquirers (EESAs). His manifesto describes building companies over decades, using equity carefully, keeping decisions close to customers, and improving businesses after buying them. He also acknowledges that the evidence is early and the sample is small.

I find the approach interesting, particularly its emphasis on long-term ownership and relationships. But I’d still investigate the specific buyer.

“We buy and hold” is a reason to ask what makes that possible. “We leave our companies independent” is a reason to ask which decisions remain with local leaders.

Do their answers “add up”? Or does the acquirer contradict themselves?

If a private equity firm is buying your agency through a fund that’s several years old, ask where the fund is in its investment cycle. They may face pressure to sell sooner than a firm investing from a newer fund.

Get into the details. Who approves a senior hire? Can the agency turn down an unsuitable client? Who sets pricing? Can the owner of the parent company replace your leadership team? Can you still work with your prior software, contractors, and advisors?

You’ll learn more from those answers than from a general statement about preserving your legacy.

Look for people who understand the work ahead

A first-time acquirer may have useful management experience and strong advisors. An experienced acquirer may be excellent at completing deals but less effective at running the companies afterward.

Evaluate those capabilities separately.

In his ETA Conference keynote, Thorndike emphasized humility, curiosity, and clear communication when discussing successful acquisition entrepreneurs. Those qualities are worth looking for in your conversations.

Does the buyer ask thoughtful questions? Can they explain the assumptions behind their plans? Do they admit when they don’t understand something?

For a first-time buyer, I’d want to know about their relevant leadership experience and who will support them after closing. For a serial acquirer, I’d want to know whether the people responsible for previous successes will be involved in this acquisition.

An impressive advisor list isn’t enough. Ask what each person will actually do. Some may help complete the transaction and then move on.

Bring the discussion back to agency management. How would the buyer handle client retention, delivery margins, scope creep, sales, and leadership development?

One question I’d ask:

“What do you believe needs to change here, and what would you need to learn before deciding?”

Pay attention to both parts of the answer. Someone who has already decided how to fix your agency after two meetings may not understand it as well as they think.

Be realistic about replacing the owner

Some acquisition entrepreneurs intend to become CEO themselves. That could be a good fit if you have a capable management team but no obvious internal successor. In contrast, a private equity-backed investor might expect you to promote or hire a CEO.

However, taking over your title and taking over your work are different challenges.

At the search panel, one speaker cautioned against buying a business where the owner does everything. The new owner can’t simply take over ten jobs.

Make a list of what you actually do. Include the work that doesn’t show up neatly on an organizational chart: rescuing a major account, coaching a department head, closing a difficult sale, or making a judgment call when delivery goes wrong.

Who will handle each responsibility after you leave? Which responsibilities could the buyer take over immediately? Which will require a transition or another hire?

I’d also ask about their experience with businesses where the work involves a lot of judgment. Agencies need processes, but a process won’t answer every question about a client relationship or a piece of creative work. Even if you productize your services, your agency isn’t a factory assembly line.

Someone from outside the industry might be excellent at this. Someone with agency experience might struggle. Ask for examples rather than deciding based on their résumé alone.

Talk through the first 100 days

The University of Chicago’s Polsky Center published a conference recap covering a panel I missed, about the first 100 days after an acquisition. Panelist Tarra Sharp described preparing around cash flow, employee relationships, and a clear transition plan with the sellers. She also traveled to meet members of her remote team.

That prompted a question I’d recommend asking a prospective buyer:

“Based on what you know so far, what would your first 100 days look like? What would you leave alone until you understood the business better?”

Listen for how they would learn about the agency and earn people’s trust. Ask which relationships would need attention first, how they would choose priorities, and what they would expect from you.

A buyer shouldn’t need to know every answer yet. But they should recognize that changing ownership will create work beyond signing documents and announcing the sale.

Keep confidentiality in mind. Discussing a transition plan doesn’t mean allowing an unqualified buyer to contact employees or clients. Agree with your advisors on when those introductions should happen.

Ask what’s behind their AI plan

If AI features heavily in the buyer’s growth plans, ask for specifics.

The Polsky Center recap also covered a panel on using AI in acquired businesses. The speakers discussed the work involved in implementation: choosing a business problem, organizing data, getting employees to use the tools, and maintaining them afterward.

For an agency buyer, I’d ask:

“Which parts of our business do you expect AI to improve, and what would it take to make that happen?”

What evidence supports their estimate? Who would do the work? How much would they invest? What happens if the improvements take longer than expected?

You don’t have to reject an ambitious plan. But you should understand how much of the buyer’s forecast depends on improvements they haven’t demonstrated.

That’s especially important when your future payments would depend on the results.

4. Get specific about culture and trust

You may genuinely like a buyer and still dislike working for them.

I think about culture in terms of the behaviors a company rewards and punishes. In an acquisition, you need to understand how those expectations would affect your team.

Ask about situations where priorities conflict. For example:

“Suppose a major client asks for work that we believe is underpriced and likely to burn out the team. How would that decision get made?”

Or:

“Tell me about a time your current business missed a financial target. What did you do?”

The answers should tell you something about how they handle financial pressure, client commitments, and employees. Ask for an actual example if the first response sounds too general.

You should also understand what they intend to integrate. Will the agency keep its name? What happens to your second-in-command? Which systems will change? Would your team retain control over hiring, delivery, and client communication?

I’ve seen the other side of this. An agency hired me two years after they acquired another firm, and the integration had gone poorly. Most of the acquired agency’s clients had left—along with nearly half of the employees. People from the acquired agency described feeling like the “losers” in the deal. The new CEO mainly visited when something went wrong, their old software had been replaced, and even calendar scheduling now revolved around the acquirer’s time zone. If a buyer has acquired firms before, ask how they handled communication, systems, and employee retention—and speak with people who lived through the transition.

Don’t expect everything to stay the same. When you sell control, you give someone else the authority to make decisions you may not like. Focus on the changes you’re willing to accept and the ones that would make you regret the sale.

Check the history behind the promises

During Thorndike’s talk, I thought of some questions to ask about the buyer’s professional relationships. How long have they worked with their accountant? Their lawyer? Their team?

The number of years isn’t a verdict. People change advisors for good reasons, and a new business won’t have decades of history. But it can give contribute meaningful insight towards larger patterns.

Ask who has worked closely with them over time. Then ask about a relationship that ended:

“What happened, and what would you do differently?”

For an experienced acquirer, speak with previous sellers through an appropriate process. In my earlier article about what agency acquirers want, I described a buyer who introduced prospective sellers to previous sellers as early as the second conversation.

It’s helpful to hear directly from someone who has already gone through the experience you’re considering with the same buyer. And it’s a sign the acquirer is confident in their process and their relationships.

Ask what surprised them after closing, how the buyer handled a serious disagreement, and whether they would sell to that buyer again.

A difficult situation handled well can be more reassuring than a reference who says everything was wonderful. You’re trying to learn how these people behave when there’s something at stake.

A first-time acquirer won’t have previous sellers to call. Look for former colleagues, business partners, or others who can speak to their leadership and reliability. This is a case where speaking with their past subordinates (instead of their past managers) would be helpful.

Pay attention to how they work with you

You’ll have opportunities to observe the buyer during the sale process.

Notice how they respond when you ask for clarification or set a reasonable boundary. Do they explain delays? Keep commitments? Correct mistakes? Respect confidentiality?

Tough negotiation isn’t necessarily a problem. A buyer can disagree with you and still be straightforward and professional. On the other hand, a friendly person can give you an evasive answer.

I’d also ask about a deal they chose not to pursue. Why did they stop? What did they learn?

That can tell you more about their judgment than another acquisition success story. A buyer who knows when to walk away may be better prepared than one who seems determined to complete a deal at any cost.

5. Compare what you’d receive—and what you’d still owe

Once there’s an offer, have your transaction team show you the proposed payments and obligations in a form you can compare with other offers. This might be their LOI or term sheet, or something else.

What would you receive at closing, after the relevant adjustments? What would arrive later? What might never arrive? What work or other commitments would remain your responsibility?

Cash at closing, a seller note, an earnout, and future equity in the buyer’s business are different things. Don’t add them together and treat the result as money in your bank account.

A seller note means you’re waiting for debt payments. An earnout makes payment depend on agreed conditions. Retained equity means some of your money remains invested in a relatively illiquid business.

Those arrangements may be worthwhile. You need to understand the risks and timing, as well as whether the proposed structure works with the buyer’s financing.

Find out what controls the earnout

An earnout can help buyer and seller agree on a price when they have different expectations about the future. It can also leave plenty to argue about unless the details are clear.

Ask what determines payment and who controls the decisions that affect it.

For an agency, I’d want to understand what happens if the buyer moves a client to another company, changes staffing, or allocates new corporate expenses to the agency. How would those changes affect the calculation? What information would you receive? How would a dispute be resolved?

Your attorney should help you understand the wording and negotiate appropriate protections. Your financial advisors should help you consider outcomes where performance falls short.

You may decide the opportunity is worth the uncertainty. But I wouldn’t base your personal plans on receiving the maximum payment.

Choose terms that fit your priorities

In one client transaction, the owners negotiated more than 80% cash at closing and a one-year earnout.

The one-year period came with demanding expectations, but they were comfortable with it. They liked receiving so much upfront and knowing relatively quickly how the additional payment would turn out.

Another seller might prefer a different arrangement. The important part was that these owners understood what mattered to them and negotiated accordingly.

That’s why I wouldn’t start by asking, “What’s the highest valuation we can get?” I’d first ask what you need from the deal. Often, that’s the amount of “cash down.” Then you and your advisors can evaluate what the proposed price and terms would actually deliver.

Give rollover equity its own evaluation

When you accept rollover equity, you’re keeping some of your money invested in the business after the sale. Treat that as an investment decision.

A question worth asking yourself:

“Would I choose to invest this amount in this business, with these individuals and these rights, if I weren’t already selling them my agency?”

Have your advisors investigate the business you would own a stake in, its debt, and the rights attached to your shares. Who gets paid before you? What information will you receive? Could others’ future decisions dilute your ownership?

Then ask how you could turn that equity into cash.

This matters when a buyer talks about owning businesses for decades. You might like that philosophy, but you still need to understand how it fits your financial plans. Would you receive distributions? Could the company repurchase your shares? Are transfers permitted? Is a future sale part of the plan?

Don’t assume that a rising valuation means you’ll be able to sell your stake when you’re ready.

Years ago, a client introduced me to a startup agency seeking board advisors. They offered equity in the business, saying they planned to exit in five years. I checked recently. A decade later, they still haven’t exited.

Read the job description along with the purchase price

Consider the role you’d be accepting after closing. It’s rare for sellers to immediately stop working for the business they just sold; your role will shift, but you likely won’t be working zero hours a week.

How many hours would you work? Who would you report to? Who could change your responsibilities? What happens if you and the buyer disagree? If you’re doing new business development, what’s your sales quota? How much time off can you take to recharge after the deal closes?

Have your attorney explain how the employment terms, restrictive covenants, and purchase agreements work together. An attractive sale price doesn’t make those obligations disappear. You may want to hire an employment attorney, on top of your M&A attorney.

Also consider how long you would remain financially tied to the agency. You might stop being the owner while still depending on the business for future payments and employment income.

That may be an acceptable arrangement. But it’s less appealing when you were expecting to be finished.

6. Before signing an LOI, find out what’s still unsettled

A letter of intent, or LOI, is an important step. Don’t treat it as harmless paperwork on the way to the “real” agreement.

Have your attorney explain which provisions would bind you, which would not, and what you would be committing to. Pay particular attention to confidentiality and exclusivity.

For most of my clients, their agency is their family’s #1 or #2 financial asset. If you don’t want to pay your lawyer to review an acquirer’s LOI before you sign it, I would ask: how serious are you about selling your agency?

A client signed an LOI that included an especially restrictive noncompete. The deal fell through for other reasons—but the owners agreed they’d reject something that harsh the next time they went on the market.

During the SBA 7(a) financing panel at the ETA Conference, a lender recommended setting an offer as a multiple of adjusted earnings. The multiple could stay the same while the purchase price fell because diligence changed the EBITDA figure.

For a seller, that’s a reason to ask:

“What assumptions are behind this price, and what could cause it to change?”

You may be picturing your life after the sale while the buyer is still deciding whether the numbers work.

Get the important assumptions into the discussion

Ask what remains subject to lender or investor approval. Find out which financial adjustments have been accepted provisionally and which still need review.

Discuss the transition, timetable, and working capital.

One lender warned about deals running into trouble late because the seller hadn’t understood how much working capital would need to remain in the business. A phrase like “a normal amount of working capital” can seem unremarkable until your accountant translates it into dollars.

You won’t resolve everything before an LOI. You should understand the unresolved issues that could change whether you’d accept the deal.

The same applies to exclusivity. Ask your attorney about its scope, duration, extensions, and what happens if the process stalls. Don’t assume you can continue entertaining other buyers once you sign a “no shop” clause.

Ask your advisors what has actually been checked

A broker or sell-side M&A advisor can help qualify buyers and manage the process. Find out what they have established about a particular buyer and what remains to be done.

Their introduction should save you work, but don’t assume that everything important has already been verified.

The level of investigation should increase as your commitment increases. Early on, you need enough information to justify another conversation. Before exclusivity, you need a stronger basis for limiting your alternatives. Before closing, the important terms need to be addressed in the agreements.

For each major promise, ask:

“What supports this, what remains conditional, and what happens if it turns out differently?”

A buyer’s assurance may be sincere. You still need evidence where it’s available and appropriate contractual protection where it matters.

Have your own paperwork ready

Expect the buyer to investigate you, too.

I call the preparation a “financial go bag”: having the documents and explanations ready in a data room before someone urgently needs them. After the SBA financing session, I compared notes with a lender who observed that when a seller is disorganized, buyers can see that as an indicator of deeper problems.

Work with your accountant and advisors on clean numbers (including accrual accounting), documented adjustments, and explanations of one-off or otherwise unusual expenses.

Some diligence findings will justify a discussion about price. If an expense you described as one-time turns out to be necessary to operate the agency, you’ll need to address that.

Other changes may reflect a buyer using your “sunk cost” investment in the process to push for a better deal—because they know you just want to get this over with. Ask your advisors to help distinguish the two.

The fact that an offer changed doesn’t settle whether the buyer acted reasonably. Look at what changed, why, and whether the revised deal still meets your needs. Try to put yourself in their shoes; that can make it seem less like a personal attack.

7. Make the decision before deal fatigue makes it for you

After enough meetings, document requests, and legal bills, it’s understandable to want the process finished.

That’s when it helps to return to the goals you wrote down at the beginning.

For each serious buyer, summarize what you know about their ability to close, their plans for the agency, and the terms they’re offering. Note the questions that remain and the risks you would accept.

You don’t need an elaborate weighted score. A high score for price won’t make up for a requirement you cannot live with.

You have three basic choices.

  • Proceed when the answers and evidence justify the next step. You’ll never eliminate all risk, but you should understand the significant risks you’re accepting.
  • Investigate further when a promising buyer leaves an important question unanswered. Be specific about the information you need and who is responsible for getting it. “Let’s keep talking” isn’t much of a plan.
  • Walk away when the mismatch is fundamental or there are more risks than you’re willing to accept. Work with your advisors and follow any agreements already in place.

Compare the offer with your actual alternatives, too. Depending on your situation, those might include another buyer, selling later after making improvements, or keeping the agency while changing your role.

You shouldn’t assume a better offer is waiting around the corner. But you also shouldn’t accept an unsuitable deal solely because you’ve already spent months on it.

Remember my client who flew to a prospective buyer’s headquarters? He could have rationalized continuing. Instead, he took what he learned seriously and ended the discussions before signing an LOI. That saved him from finding out after closing that he didn’t want to work for the people who now owned his agency.

Choose someone you’re willing to hand the business to

You’ve put years into building your agency. It’s reasonable to ask detailed questions of someone who wants to buy it.

A buyer doesn’t need to have every answer at the first meeting. They should be willing to explain their plans, acknowledge what they still need to learn, and work through questions with you.

Do the work early enough to use what you learn. Ask who will run the agency, how they’ll finance it, and what they’ll expect from you. Check references. Understand the payments and obligations before you start planning around them.

An acquisition inquiry can be flattering—but turning a promising inquiry into a good exit requires thorough investigation.

For help preparing your agency for a sale or evaluating the business and leadership implications of an offer, contact me. I work with agency owners alongside their transaction advisors to clarify what they want and decide how to get there.

You’ve outgrown guesswork.

The Agency Value Audit gives you a clear diagnosis of what’s really going on—and a prioritized plan for what to do next, so you can build a stronger, more valuable agency with more options over time.